Listen to new episodes out now on Spotify.
April 7, 2020
Episode 8: Reunion (Season 2)
Conviction
After 23 years, John comes face to face with his father Melvin.
March 31, 2020
Episode 7: The Kids Grow Up (Season 2)
More than a decade after the first allegations of satanic ritual abuse in California, the Satanic Panic was mostly snuffed out. The nation began to move on. But the children at the heart of it were just beginning to reckon with their past.
March 24, 2020
Episode 6: The State vs. Melvin Quinney (Season 2)
In the summer of 1991, Melvin Quinney was put on trial. The prime witness against him: his own son, John.
March 17, 2020
Episode 5: The Making Of A Cult Victim (Season 2)
Back in Texas, after Debbie Quinney accused her husband of abusing his children and leading a satanic cult, their children were placed in a shelter. Not long after this, nine-year-old John Quinney entered a controversial form of psychotherapy that was hugely popular in the 1980s. Today, he thinks that therapy might have brainwashed him.
March 10, 2020
Episode 4: How Do You Outrun A Panic? (Season 2)
By 1985, California was fully engulfed in a panic. People were convinced that there was an underground network of satanists abusing children right under their noses, and everyone was a suspect. Children who were taken away for questioning often didn't return. Parents, friends, and neighbors were arrested without evidence to support the charges. In the midst of this frenzy, one family packed their b...
March 3, 2020
Episode 3: Believe The Children (Season 2)
In the 1980s, protecting the safety of children became a paramount concern. It was the one issue that could unite even the most disparate factions of society, from radical leftists to Christian conservatives. But the movement to protect children quickly morphed into an all-consuming panic that pushed parents, therapists, and police to view all children as victims—even if the children claimed otherw...
February 25, 2020
Episode 2: The Panic Begins (Season 2)
We trace the roots of the Satanic Panic back to a strange Canadian memoir, Michelle Remembers. In it, a woman named Michelle describes satanic rituals she was forced to participate in as a child. She “recovered” these memories with the help of her psychotherapist, who coined the term ritual abuse. In this episode, we track how the idea of satanic ritual abuse jumped from the pages of a suspicious b...
Episode 1: Meet The Quinneys (Season 2)
In 1989, nine-year-old John Quinney accused his father Melvin of being a satanic cult leader and abusing him in satanic rituals. His father vehemently denied the charges. It was a case that tore their family apart. But what none of them knew was that they were just one of dozens of families going through the same nightmare.
January 28, 2020
Introducing Conviction: American Panic
When John Quinney was ten years old, he took the stand to testify against his own father. He had come to believe that his dad Melvin was the murderous leader of a satanic cult. It would be decades before John would learn that his family was just one of many swept up in a panic that gripped America in the 1980s—one in which hundreds of people were accused of taking part in underground satanic cults ...
February 4, 2019
Part 7: No Angels
Pedro’s trial date finally arrives, and Manny sets out on another quest. Will he finally push the envelope too far?
Part 6: Right Past the Sun
Manny takes some big risks that could get Pedro’s case dismissed—or could get Pedro into even deeper trouble.
Part 5: The Wrong Guy
Manny’s quest to free Pedro isn’t just about justice. It’s payback.
Part 4: No Wins
Terrell believes that Manny and his clients are out to destroy his career. But they aren’t the only ones sounding alarms about Terrell.
Part 3: The Cop
Manny meets a key witness. Saki meets Manny’s nemesis.
Part 2: The Porsche
Pedro gets pushed to take a plea deal. Manny goes on a quest to find the one young man who can free him.
Part 1: The Private Eye
Private Investigator Manuel Gomez takes on the biggest case of his career: the case of Pedro Hernandez.
We've updated our Terms of Service. Learn More
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More