The pursuit of justice drives two men to fight each other in the courts and on the streets of New York.
Based on host Saki Knafo's reporting for The New York Times Magazine as a reporting fellow with Type Investigations.
February 4, 2019
Part 1: The Private Eye
Private Investigator Manuel Gomez takes on the biggest case of his career: the case of Pedro Hernandez.
Part 2: The Porsche
Pedro gets pushed to take a plea deal. Manny goes on a quest to find the one young man who can free him.
Part 3: The Cop
Manny meets a key witness. Saki meets Manny’s nemesis.
Part 4: No Wins
Terrell believes that Manny and his clients are out to destroy his career. But they aren’t the only ones sounding alarms about Terrell.
Part 5: The Wrong Guy
Manny’s quest to free Pedro isn’t just about justice. It’s payback.
Part 6: Right Past the Sun
Manny takes some big risks that could get Pedro’s case dismissed—or could get Pedro into even deeper trouble.
Part 7: No Angels
Pedro’s trial date finally arrives, and Manny sets out on another quest. Will he finally push the envelope too far?
July 18, 2019
Introducing The Clearing
Listen to the first episode of this new true crime podcast from Pineapple Street Media and Gimlet.
August 7, 2019
Introducing Crimetown Season 2: Detroit. Binge the whole season on Spotify, or listen weekly wherever you get your podcasts.